Quinnipiac University

Professor sees our common humanity as a means of preventing a future event like 9/11

By Hillary Haldane, director of general education and professor of anthropology September 08, 2021

Hillary Haldane, director of general education

It is impossible to measure the overall impact that 9/11 had on the discipline of anthropology.

One of the most significant and influential essays of the last twenty years emerged in less than a year after the terrible attacks: Lila Abu-Lughod's "Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving? Anthropological Reflections on Cultural Relativism and Its Others," published in September 2002 in the American Anthropologist, the flagship journal of the discipline.

The essay by Professor Abu-Lughod captured so much of the ambivalence around our response to 9/11 — the need and desire to end terrorism, the concern for vulnerable peoples to have equitable access to resources, and for all humans to strive to be more understanding of one another. 9/11 happened because the US represented something negative to a small yet mobilized group of people. Would it be possible for us to avoid and prevent future 9/11s if we could see ourselves in others, if all peoples on this planet realized our species being, our common humanity?

My hope is that 9/11, when studied in the future by my discipline, will be remembered for the tragic loss of life, the harm done to numerous communities, the voluntary service of so many young women and men who didn't think twice about joining the military, and the fact that the tragic events of that day were completely avoidable. Humans are capable of so much, yet we resort to grotesque acts of hate and harm. We are so much better than this, we need to be better than this. 

If my discipline can play a small role in helping to erode the misunderstandings, the gross stereotypes, the harmful assumptions we make about our fellow beings, that will be the greatest tribute we can offer to those who lost their lives twenty years ago, and to the numerous service members and civilians who suffered in the wars that followed.

Related Articles

Headshot of Stefano Fasulo

Administrator walks the extra mile to help first-responders

I was beginning my third year in the School of Communications’ journalism program at Hofstra University on Long Island. While getting ready for my 9 a.m. class, my roommate yelled out to come look at the TV. Still, 20 years later, the scene that played out seemed surreal; an action movie with special effects.

Read More
Jeff Cooper

9/11 forced the legal profession to rethink worst-case scenario

As a lawyer, I was trained to help clients prepare for “the worst.” The events of 9/11 made me and the legal profession rethink exactly what that meant.

Read More
Sal Bondoc

9/11 changed the way occupational therapy is practiced

The events of September 11 convinced me to remain as an OT, and on a much larger scale, 9/11 changed OT practice in a number of ways.

Read More
A bench honors those lost on 9/11

Remembering forever members of the Quinnipiac community

The names of Frank H. Brennan ’72, James C. Cappers ’92 and Timothy C. Kelly ’85 are carved in a granite bench outside the Pat Abbate ’58 Alumni House and Gardens at Quinnipiac.

Read More
Valerie Smith, Associate Professor of English for the College of Arts and Sciences at Quinnipiac University.

Impossibilities that are suddenly possible

I was scrambling around to get to my early class in First-Year Writing when my husband came barreling into the room. It was my very first semester of teaching at Quinnipiac.

Read More

Stay in the Loop

Sign Up Now